Call Us: 724-888-6418
Email Us: info@neillandsonroofing.com
The best shingles for your home work with your roof’s slope, handle local weather, and fit your budget and style. For homeowners considering shingle roofing, that means looking beyond color to consider rain, wind, snow, and attic moisture. We’ll walk through shingle types, features worth comparing, and what to check before hiring a contractor.
Key Takeaways:
|
When comparing asphalt shingle roofing, you’ll generally see these three options.
Three-tab shingles have a flat, uniform appearance and may offer a lower upfront price, though availability and performance depend on the product.
Architectural shingles use a layered design for a thicker, dimensional appearance and offer a range of colors and performance features.
Designer shingles create more detailed profiles, sometimes resembling slate or wood shakes, for homeowners willing to spend more on appearance.
Follow these five steps to narrow your options before choosing a product.
Have a contractor inspect the shingles, decking, flashing, and roof slope so you know whether repairs are practical or replacement makes more sense.
Point out wind damage, shaded roof sections, and winter ice buildup so your contractor can address those concerns in the roofing plan.
Include removal, disposal, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and possible decking repairs so your budget covers more than the visible shingles.
View full-size samples outside and look at completed roofs with similar brick, siding, and roof slopes before making your choice.
Ask who will install your roof, how they follow manufacturer instructions, and which material and workmanship warranties you’ll receive.
When you search for top rated residential roof shingles, compare the exact product’s features instead of relying on a brand name or online ranking.
Check the product’s wind coverage and required installation methods, including fastening and starter shingles, because coverage depends on meeting specific conditions.
An impact rating reflects performance in a controlled test, so ask what the rating means without treating it as a guarantee against storm damage.
Algae-resistant shingles can help limit dark streaks, but they do not eliminate moss, falling leaves, or the need for maintenance.
Read the coverage period, exclusions, transfer rules, and any reduction in benefits over time, then ask separately about installation coverage.
Shingles shed water, but your roof also relies on the materials beneath them and the details around openings. A new surface may leave an existing chimney leak unresolved if damaged flashing stays in place. Manufacturers describe shingles, underlayment, ice and water barriers, and ventilation as parts of a complete roofing system.
Ask your contractor to check:
1. Flashing: Metal around chimneys, walls, and roof openings needs careful inspection.
2. Underlayment: The layer beneath your shingles provides added protection.
3. Ice and water protection: Vulnerable areas need protection suited to the roof and installation requirements.
4. Attic airflow: Intake and exhaust vents need to work together.
5. Roof decking: Soft or damaged wood needs attention before new shingles go down.
For example, an older home in Western Pennsylvania might have blocked soffit vents beneath newer siding, making an attic inspection useful before replacement. IKO recommends reviewing ventilation during reroofing, including whether there are enough vents, whether they are positioned correctly, and whether they are clear of obstructions.
Ask each contractor to price the same scope of work so you can understand what explains the difference. An estimate that includes new flashing, ventilation changes, and full removal covers more work than one listing only shingles and labor. Before choosing, get unclear items explained in writing.
Your estimate should identify:
1. Exact shingles: Manufacturer, product line, color, and relevant performance ratings.
2. Removal and disposal: Existing layers being removed and how debris will leave your property.
3. Decking repairs: How hidden damage will be documented and priced.
4. Flashing work: Which pieces will be replaced and which may remain.
5. Ventilation work: Any planned changes to intake or exhaust vents.
6. Property protection: Plans for landscaping, cleanup, and collecting loose nails.
7. Warranty details: Written material coverage and the contractor’s workmanship terms.
If two estimates differ, ask, “What work does your price include that the other estimate may leave out?” That gives you a useful starting point without assuming the highest or lowest price offers the best value.
Here are answers to five questions that often come up when choosing shingles.
Architectural asphalt shingles are worth comparing for their dimensional appearance and available performance features. The best choice for your Pittsburgh home depends on its slope, exposure, budget, and the complete installation plan.
There is no single lifespan that applies to every asphalt shingle roof. Product quality, installation, ventilation, weather exposure, and maintenance all affect how long your roof lasts.
They can be worth it if you prefer their appearance or want features available in a particular product line. Ask your contractor to explain the actual upgrade so you know what your additional spending buys.
Yes, isolated damage may be repairable when the surrounding shingles and underlying roof remain in good condition. Widespread wear, brittle shingles, or repeated leaks may make replacement a better use of your money.
No, a lifetime warranty has terms, exclusions, and eligibility requirements. Ask what it covers, whether labor is included, and how the benefits change over time.
Not sure which shingles fit your home or whether you need a replacement? At Neill & Son Roofing, we’ll assess your roof and walk you through your residential roofing options. Contact us today for an estimate for your home in Pittsburgh or Western Pennsylvania.